Application - 2 Coulomb Crystals

Background

The purpose of this resaerch is to investigate the structure and dynamics of so-called ions trapped in a electric and magnetic field (Paul Trap). Ion Coulomb Crystals are the solid state of plasma containing only particles of the same sign of charge. One-component plasma (OCP's) consist only of one single ion species. OCP's at low temperatures have been studied intensively theoretically and during the last 10 years also experimentally with laser cooled ions in traps. Ions in free space repel each other due to Coulomb force repulsion and expand to infinity. In a trap (Fig. below) an additional attractive potential keeps the system bounded. For certain parameters of the potential the most favorable energetic configuration (the state with lowest energy) of the ions will be to organize them self in a linear string. Such a string is at present one of the most promising candidates for implementing a quantum processor, which have the potential of solving classical exponential problems in linear time.

Paul Trap

In classical mechanics the dynamics of the particles is determined by Newtons 2. law,

Newton's equations of motion

The forces can be calculated from the potential energy function

Force

The potential is a sum of electrostatic repulsions and trap attractions,

Potential (electrostatic repulsions and trap attractions)

where Positions is the coordinate of particle i. The mass Mi is defined in [amu], qi, qj are defined in [e] and Coulomb factor.

From experimentalists we learn that a typical trap parameter:

Experimental Omega value

For example, assuming a weaker one can observe a transition from a 1-dimensional string (41 Ca+, MPEG, 322KB) to a 2-dimesional zig-zag line (42 Ca+, MPEG, 320KB) by increasing the number of ions.

We investigate for increasing numbers of ions whether they converge to shell structure or not, especially for bi-crystals. Our computer simulation are performed with the object-oriented component based molecular dynamics framework ProtoMol. In order to solve larger-sized simulation problems we use the multi-grid method, which performs for large system about 100-600 times faster and a maximum relative force error of order 10-3 compared to the direct method. For the convergence to shell or lattice structure this accuracy is appropriated. If needed, one may run some few final steps with a more accurate method. This ongoing project is a collaboration with Michael Drewsen who provides experimental data.

ProtoMol

ProtoMol is an object-oriented component based framework for molecular dynamics simulations. The framework supports the CHARMM 19 and 28a2 force fields and is able to process PDB, PSF, XYZ and DCD trajectory files. It is designed for high flexibility, easy extendibility and maintenance, and high performance demands, including parallelization. The technique of multiple time-stepping has been used to improve long-term efficiency, and the use of fast electrostatic force evaluation algorithms like plain Ewald, Particle Mesh Ewald, and Multigrid summation further improves performance. Longer time steps are possible using MOLLY, Langevin Molly and Hybrid Monte Carlo, Nose-Hoover, and Langevin integrators. In addition, ProtoMol has been designed to interact with VMD, a visualization engine developed by the University of Illinois that is used for displaying large biomolecular systems in three dimensions. ProtoMol is free distributed software, and the source code will be included.

ProtoMol is been developed in collaboration with J.A. Izaguirre and members of the LCLS Group; CSE Department, University of Notre Dame, Indiana, USA.

Computer Simulation and Results

Newtons 2. law is solved by a Leap-Frog integrator scheme with Nose-Hoover thermostat, starting with an initial temperature of ~1mK and cooled down to ~1uK. The simulation runs represent 1ms with an integration step of 100ns. The start configuration has a different density distribution compared to the final configuration, such that the temperature will temporally increase in the beginning of the simulation. The Coulombic part was computed directly for small system sizes, whereas a multi-grid method was used for the largest system size.

Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere
2057 Ca+40; Direct method (config, 434K archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere a b
1029 Ca+40 and 1028 A2+80; Direct method (config, 454K archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere
20288 Ca+40; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 1.4M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere
17752 Ca+40 and 2536 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 1.4M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere
15216 Ca+40 and 5072 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 1.4M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere a b
10144 Ca+40 and 10144 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 1.4M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere
5072 Ca+40 and 15216 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 1.4M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere
2536 Ca+40 and 17752 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 1.4M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial Outer hemisphere
20288 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 1.4M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial m (1ms), m (10ns) Outer hemisphere
100000 Ca+40; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 6.5M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial m (1ms), m (10ns) Outer hemisphere
50000 Ca+40 and 50000 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 6.5M archive)
Radial distribution, initial Plane |z| <= 10um, initial Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial
Radial distribution Plane |z| <= 10um Radii-interval, ((r_i-1 + r_i)/2, r_i - r_i-1) and r_k = ||x_k||, r_i < r_j <=> i < j, initial m (1ms) m (10ns) Outer hemisphere
100000 A2+80; Multigrid, FE=4.10-3 (config, 6.5M archive)

Related Links

TTP5 Presentation - Status Report

  • Bergen 25/6 2001 (PDF)
  • Tromsø 14/12 2001 (PDF)
  • Oslo 11/06 2002 (PDF)
  • Fevik 30/08 2002 (PDF)

Last modified: .




A Technology Transfer Project funded by NOTUR